HQSS Bellagio Forum
June 4-8, 2018
From June 4-8 we met with a group of senior policymakers and advocates from countries, multi-lateral and bi-lateral organizations and foundations for a rich set of discussions around the Commission’s findings. Set at the Rockefeller Foundation Center in beautiful Bellagio, Italy, we previewed the key highlights of the report and discussed how to move from evidence to action on several themes. WHO Director General Dr. Tedros sent a video to open the meeting and express support for this agenda, which you can view here.
HQSS Bellagio Forum Participants
1.Margaret Kruk, Associate Professor, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health
2.Muhammad Pate, CEO, Big Win Philanthropy
3.Zoë Mullan, Editor, Lancet Global Health
4.Anna Gage, HQSS Commission Coordinator, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health
5.Catherine Arsenault, Post-Doctoral Fellow, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health
6.Sanam Roder-DeWan, Post-Doctoral Fellow, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health
National policy makers
7.Malebona Precious Matsoso*, Director General, Department of Health South Africa
8.Gagan Thapa*, Member of Parliament, Nepal
9.Sebastián García Saisó*, General Director of Quality and Education in Health, Secretary of Health Mexico
10.Ernest Konadu Asiedu, National Quality Management Unit Head, PPMED Ministry of Health Ghana
11.Manoj Jhalani, Additional Secretary and Mission Director, National Health Mission India
12.Walid Ammar, Director-General, Ministry of Public Health Lebanon Foundations
13.Mary Ann Etiebet, Executive Director, Merck for Mothers
14.Dana Hovig, Director of Integrated Delivery, Gates Foundation
15.Kate Somers*, Senior Program Officer, Gates Foundation
16.Alma Golden, Deputy Assistant Administrator for Global Health, USAID
17.Alex Schulze, Co-head of Division Global Programme Health, Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation
18.Lizzie Smith, Chief Scientific Advisor, DFID
19.Yusuhisa Shiozaki, Member of the House of Representatives, Japan
20.Annegret Al-Janabi, Senior Policy Advisor, German Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development
21.Peter Hansen, Health of Technical Advice and Partnerships, The Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Malaria and TB
22.Stefan Peterson, Chief of Health, UNICEF
23.Ian Forde, Senior Health Specialist, World Bank
24.Blerta Maliqi, Technical Officer, World Health Organization
25.Frederico Guanais*, Principal Health Specialist, Inter-American Development Bank Civil society
26.Batool Al-Wahdani, Vice President for External Affairs, International Federation of Medical Students
27.Kadar Marikar, CEO, Malaysian Society for Quality in Health
*Additional Commission affiliates
Second Meeting of the HQSS Commission, December 11-15, Johannesburg, South Africa
Even as snow shut down airports and cancelled flights from the US to the Netherlands, HQSS Commissioners, secretariat, and national commission representatives made their way to Johannesburg, SA for the second meeting of the HQSS Commission. Co-hosted by the Department of Health of South Africa, this meeting was an opportunity to share the key challenges facing health systems in the definition, measurement, and improvement of quality.
The first two days of meetings were an opportunity for national commissions to share their countries’ successes and challenges in measuring and improving quality. Representatives from nine countries presented their work: Argentina, Ethiopia, Mexico, Malawi, Nepal, Philippines, Senegal, South Africa, and Tanzania.
Wednesday, December 13th was a public session meant to share the Commission’s work with the public and attended by over 100 stakeholders. The Honorable Minister of Health of South Africa, Aaron Motsoaledi, opened the meeting by reminding the audience that quality is a non-negotiable commitment of health systems to people. Other speakers included Ms. Gwendoline Ramokgopa, Member of the Executive Committee of Gauteng Province and Commissioner Precious Matsosos, Director General of the Department of Health. Following the presentations, panels on the Quality of Care in South Africa and the HQSS National Commissions presented their work and engaged in discussion with the audience.
In the final two days of the meeting, HQSS global Commissioners and research team reviewed the first draft of the Commission’s report. Following the meeting, the research staff will continue to revise the report with the aim of submitting to Lancet Global Health in February 2018.
Click through the photos below, and be sure to check out the HQSS Blog in January for reflections on the meeting from the participants.
HQSS Boston Inception Meeting, March 13th – 15th
Despite icy temperatures and one of the worst Boston snowfalls of Winter 2017, Commissioners, Advisory Council members, and researchers convened for the inception meeting of the Lancet Global Health HQSS Commission from March 13th to 15th.
The three-day meeting began with a full-day public event co-hosted by Harvard Global Health Institute and the HQSS Commission. The event challenged speakers, Commissioners, and over 300 in-person and web-based audience members to stir debate and ask new questions on defining and delivering quality in health systems of low and middle income countries. Learn more about the first day here.
The second and third days of the inception meeting were restricted to Commissioners and the Advisory Council. Both days focused on setting the agenda for the Commission’s work over the next two years. Commissioners and Advisory Council members outlined and organized Commission efforts into four working groups, Definition and Description, Measurement, Improvement, and Ethics and Equity.
Commissioners also discussed plans to establish National Commissions – independent commissions on quality within countries. Several countries will begin establishing national commissions, more information will be posted on our website as National Commissions are finalized.
Throughout the two days, Commissioners emphasized several themes: 1. Patients are at the center of quality efforts and are arbiters of quality; 2. Quality measurement must be efficient and focused on what matters most rather than what is easily measured; 3. Equity is integral – health systems must provide quality for all people.
Following the meeting, Commissioners and researchers will begin work on analyses and research. Check out our HQSS Blog and new research under Our Work for up-to-date activities of the HQSS Commission.
Launch of WHO Bulletin themed issue on quality of care
June 14th, 2017 | WHO Bulletin themed issue launch | Geneva, Switzerland
On June 14, the WHO and UNU-WIDER hosted the launch of the WHO Bulletin special theme issue on measuring quality of care. Co-edited by Commission Chair Dr. Margaret Kruk, the issue pulls together new evidence on how to measure and how to improve quality of care from around the world. The launch brought together five authors of the articles to discuss their work on clinical observations of delivery in Uttar Pradesh, infection prevention measures in Kenya, community-based approaches for neonatal survival, indicators for quality of maternal and newborn care, and quality variation in primary care. In addition to the presentations of research, policy makers from Liberia, Indonesia, Mexico and Ethiopia spoke about their experiences with quality of care.
One recurring theme throughout the issue and the panel was the need to generate demand for quality within communities. Speakers drew an analogy to the improvement in access to care: access only improved once communities started demanding it. Similarly, the movement for quality must begin with people’s expectations of what care they are entitled to. Expectations for quality of care are low in many areas currently; satisfaction with care is high despite persistent indications of poor quality. Suggestions on how to increase demand were discussed, including engaging communities in facility learning collaboratives, strengthening patient feedback mechanisms, and publishing facility report cards.
Launch of the South Africa National Commission for High Quality Health Systems
May 11-12th, 2017 | Launch of the South Africa National HQSS Commission | Pretoria, South Africa
The South Africa National HQSS Commission held its first meeting on May 11th and celebrated its formal launch on May 12th, 2017.
The commission’s first meeting resulted in the adoption of a definition of quality as health care that is safe, timely, effective, efficient, equitable, accessible, ethical, and person centered. The commission further resolved to establish two working groups, one on quality improvement and one on ethics, to conduct the commission’s work. Major goals of these groups include conducting a national social media survey on priorities for health system quality and analyzing quality of care by province, rurality, gender, and socioeconomic status. As a whole, the commission aims to deliver:
- Compendium of established standards for quality health care
- Descriptive analysis of quality across the country and across key demographic groups, including mapping of national and subnational health system quality and identification of key quality challenges by strata
- A single framework for quality in the national health system
- Compendium of current quality improvement projects
- New analyses addressing priority questions for the country
- Policy briefs synthesizing recommendations from the commission’s activities
Following these deliberations, the commission was officially launched on May 12th at an event attended by dozens of key stakeholders, including experts from the private and public sectors as well as professional associations, academia, and labor. Deputy Minister of Health Dr. Joe Phaahla celebrated the occasion of the launch and applauded the commission for its global leadership. Stakeholders provided important suggestions and insights on how the work of the commission can best inform health care delivery in South Africa.
Full details of the first meeting and launch can be found here.
Inception meeting of the HQSS Commission – see agenda and video links below!
March 13th, 2017 | High Quality Health Systems: A Global Agenda forum, Lancet Global Health HQSS Commission | Boston, USA
On March 13th, 2017, global leaders in academia, government, community organizations and non-governmental entities convened at Harvard Medical School to kick off the Lancet Global Health HQSS Commission. The event, titled “High Quality Health Systems: A Global Agenda”, attracted more than 300 in-person and web-based attendees. Scroll down for webcast links.
Co-hosted by the Lancet Global Health HQSS Commission and the Harvard Global Health Institute, the event featured two panels and four rapid-fire sessions with leading experts in academia, global health, and government. The meeting began with a short video from people around the world explaining what high quality health care means to them and describing their experiences with health systems. See the video here. The event highlighted key obstacles facing health systems in defining, measuring, and improving quality, challenging panelists and audience members to rethink basic assumptions about health system quality. Panelists included both US and global health system experts, patient advocates, and academics.
Commission co-chairs, Margaret Kruk, Associate Professor at Harvard Chan School of Public Health and Muhammad Pate, Former Minister of State for Health of Nigeria introduced the HQSS Commission and outlined the Commission’s work over the next two years. “The Commission will attempt to refocus the world’s attention on the process of care and its outcomes, including the value that health care brings to patients.” Kruk said. Pate emphasized the value of the Commission for giving concrete guidance to improve quality in low and middle income countries, particularly in Africa.
Throughout the day, panelists and audience members highlighted the need for greater focus on patient experience and practical, real-world solutions for measuring and improving health system quality in low and middle income countries.
Following this one-day public event, Commissioners and researchers convened for a two-day work meeting. Learn more about the full #HQSSBoston event here. Scroll below for a complete agenda of the day, and select tweets from the event.
Click on the session titles or images to watch recordings.
SCHEDULE – Click on session titles or images for webcast recordings!
The HQSS Commission introduction video asks people from seven countries around the world why quality is important for them, and how quality can be improved in their context.
Speakers: Muhammad Pate, Former Minister of Health, Nigeria, CEO, Big Win Philanthropy; Susan Edgman-Levitan, Executive Director,
Stoeckle Center for Primary Care Innovation at MGH; Ashish Jha, Director, Harvard Global Health Institute; Ephrem Tekle Lemango, Maternal and Child Health Directorate, Ministry of Health, Ethiopia
Speakers: Donald Berwick, Former Administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services; Christina Åkerman, President, International Consortium for Health Outcomes Measurement; Andrew Ho, Professor, Harvard Graduate School of Education; Robert Huckman, Professor, Harvard Business School; Helen Burstin, Chief Scientific Officer, The Quality Forum
12:30 – 1:30 PM | Lunch
1:30 – 4:30 PM | Session 3. State of the science: hot topics in quality (Webcast recording links to each topic below)
Speakers: Olusoji Adeyi, Director, Health, Nutrition and Population Global Practice, World Bank; Edward Kelly, Coordinator and Head of Strategic Programmes, Patient Safety, World Health Organization; Nana Twum-Danso, Founder and Chief Executive Officer, Maza Transport, Ghana
Speakers: Pierre Barker, Chief Global Partnerships and Programs Officer, Institute for Healthcare Improvement; Frederico Guanais, Health Lead Specialist, Inter-American Development Bank, Peru; Alexander Rowe, Medical Epidemiologist, Malaria Branch, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, USA
Speakers: Ashish Jha, Director, Harvard Global Health Institute; Professor, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health; Joshua Salomon, Professor, Department of Global Health and Population, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health; Svetlana Doubova, Head of the Epidemiology and Health Services Research Unit at the Mexican Institute of Social Security
Speakers: Muhammad Pate, Former Minister of Health, Nigeria; CEO, Big Win Philanthropy; Ole Norheim, Professor, University of Bergen, Norway; Youssoupha Ndiaye, Regional Health Director, Extended Program of Immunization, Senegal
4:30 to 5:00 PM | Summary
Closing remarks and next steps for the Lancet Global Health HQSS Commission
HQSS Chair presents keynote address at Quality, Equity and Dignity event
February 14th, 2017 | Launch of the Network for Improving Quality of Care for Maternal, Newborn, and Child Health | Lilongwe, Malawi
Dr. Margaret Kruk, chair of the HQSS Commission, presenting keynote address at the launch of the Network for Improving Quality of Care for Maternal, Newborn and Child Health.
Convened by WHO and UNICEF in collaboration with the Government of Malawi, the launch meeting of the Network for Improving Quality of Care for Maternal, Newborn and Child Health brought together over 350 stakeholders from nine governments, private organizations and academia. The event generated support and a realization of commitments to ending preventable maternal and newborn mortality, as defined under the Every Woman Every Child Global Strategy for women’s, children’s, and adolescents’ health. The Network aims to operationalize a common vision for quality, equity, and dignity in health care for mothers and newborns throughout pregnancy, childbirth, and postnatal periods. By investing in this quality goal, nine committed countries – Bangladesh, Cote d’Ivoire, Ethiopia, Ghana, India, Tanzania, Malawi, Nigeria and Uganda – aim to halve stillbirths and maternal and newborn deaths in participating health facilities over five years.
Dr. Kruk’s address highlighted four key observations about quality, challenging meeting attendees to reset the quality agenda:
- Quality is for people. High quality health care is a basic promise from the health system to its users. Focusing on people means we organize care to maximize health and ensure that people feel heard and respected while receiving care.
- Quality care is the core mission of health systems. What is the purpose of a hospital or a health facility without quality care? Quality care is not a specialized pursuit for select conditions or select countries. It is fundamental to health systems and the provision of care.
- Measure quality by what matters. Simply counting inventory is not a sufficient or accurate indicator of quality. Health is a service industry, and it is due time for us to consider customer opinion.
- It is time to challenge basic assumptions. Quality improvement is not a new enterprise, and we are long overdue for a quality reset. For example, does results-based financing lift the performance of a health system, or temporarily increase the incentivized interventions? New thinking for structural change and service delivery is needed.